Freedom Folks

Tuesday, April 18, 2006

A Taste Of The Crazy...

If you didn't give a rat's ass about this country or feel your citizenship amounted to anything of value you might write something like this...
Well, I agree. Creating a Dubai-style underclass of disenfranchised immigrants who have few rights and even less voice in the country they help prop up is an awful idea. That's why everyone should oppose "guest worker" policies that allow companies to import a captive labor force that are here at the mercy of their employers, can't bargain for better wages, speak out against shoddy work conditions, or organize and strike. But I'd go even farther. Why should non-citizens have to be disenfranchised? Why not just let anyone living here legally vote?

It seems a bit crazy, but it's worth putting out there. Non-citizen immigrants seem to be constitutionally barred from voting at the federal level in any case, but nothing's stopping anyone from giving them the vote in state and local elections. And why not? Presumably immigrants should have a say in, for instance, what goes on in the schools they're sending their kids to. And it's perfectly possible: Takoma Park in Maryland allows non-citizens to vote, although I don't think it's affected voter participation or local politics very much there. (San Francisco has considered similar measures at various points, too—it's unsettling, by the way, that 4.6 million people in California, one-fifth of the state population, can't vote.)

Who knows, a bit of civic participation might even make immigrants more "patriotic" or "assimilated" or whatever it is nativists worry about. (Even though the evidence shows that even Hispanic immigrants are assimilating just fine.) At the very least, non-citizen voting would help prevent the United States from turning into another Dubai. It's just not very likely to happen, although maybe a well-placed and influential New York Times columnist could do his part to help this idea gain momentum...
Those darn nativists!

How dare they care about this country? One wonders precisely what this joker was smoking before he wrote this tripe? Oh, he was jacked up on Starbucks Frappucino Latte's and the creaking sound his swollen cranium makes?

Fair enough.

Here's a preview of what would happen if we followed Senor Jackasses advice. Warning, it ain't pretty.

H/T LoneWacko

Technorati Tags: , ,



Create a Link

<< Home